Vicar

Before stepping into the role of Vicar of All Souls, David served as a teacher and academic dean at a Christian high school in Indianapolis for twenty years. Prior, David worked with Youth for Christ and as an associate pastor of a church plant in Colorado.

David earned his Masters of Divinity from Denver Seminary in 2003 and was ordained into the priesthood in 2023. He has has been serving in leadership at All Souls since 2018.

David and his wife Kelli have three children—two in high school and one in college. They love to share music, travel, books, art, theatre, and film as a family.

One of David’s favorite quotes: "All those who have been once affected inwardly by the worldly beauty of either nature, or of a person’s life, or of art, will surely not insist that they have no genuine idea of what beauty is. The beautiful brings forth with it a self-evidence that en-lightens without mediation.” (Hans Urs von Balthasar)

Curate/Assisting Priest

Esteban is originally from Valladolid, Spain. He moved to the United States to finish his high school education. He graduated from Moody Bible Institute in 2019 and from Trinity Anglican Seminary in 2021. He earned a PhD focused on St Teresa of Ávila through St Mary's University (London) in 2025.

He was ordained as a deacon in 2024 and as a priest in 2026. He is currently serving as a curate at All Souls. 

Esteban and his wife, Abby, have three young children. He enjoys reading, taking siestas, playing with his kids, and eating unhurried meals with family and friends.

One of Esteban's favorite quotes: "What people don't realize is how much religion costs. They think faith is a big electric blanket, when of course it is the cross. It is much harder to believe than not to believe." (Flannery O'Connor)

Deacon

Garrett currently serves as a Dean at Coram Deo Academy in Indianapolis. He also teaches Latin, Greek, Logic, and Humanities.

Garrett graduated with his B.A. in Biblical Exposition from Moody Bible Institute and then received his MDiv. from Grand Rapids Theological Seminary. Previous to joining All Souls, he has served as a youth pastor, a solo pastor, and a worship pastor.  

Garrett and his wife Andrea have five children. He enjoys reading, listening to music albums in one sitting, trying new recipes, playing chess, guitar, and going for walks. 

One of Garrett’s favorite quotes: "In his purpose to reveal himself to mankind, and to enter healingly within human existence, God refused to allow our limitations and weaknesses to inhibit his purpose of love and redemption. He condescended in incredible humility to find a way of entering within our beggarly weakness and poverty, to find a mode of divine entry into our finite and moral existence, in order from within as Creator and Savior to restore us to complete fellowship with himself, both and knowing and in being." (T.F. Torrance)

Priest and NAMS Midwest Director

Dave has served in full-time ministry since 1981. He graduated from The Trinity School of Ministry and was ordained to the priesthood in 1990. He served as an assistant pastor in VA, followed by 22 years of ministry in Michigan. In 2005 he joined AMIA (Anglican Mission in America) and started a new work in Flint, Michigan, followed by his move to Indianapolis to help launch All Souls.

In June of 2024, Dave moved into a new role as a a church planter with the New Anglican Mission Society (NAMS), helping to launch other Anglican fellowships in central Indiana.

Dave has been married to his wife, Debra, for 44 years. They have 4 grown children and 7 grandchildren. They enjoy walking many of the Indy trails and parks, cheering on The Indy Eleven, engaging the arts, and sharing meals with friends.

One of Dave’s favorite quotes: “Our true worth is not in what we possess, but in Who possesses us.” (Charles Simeon)